Love Stinks (S03E02)

Puck and Rachel's flirtation kicks off during a church visit and continues through their subsequent outings. Pedro is disgusted when Puck digs into the communal peanut butter with his fingers. Puck decides to bail on a much-anticipated double date for Valentine's Day, and when Rachel offers to step in, he turns her down. During a house meeting, Rachel fails to convince everyone to create separate bathrooms for males and females, leading Puck to feel singled out for his messy habits. Rachel and Pedro chat about their living situation and her curiosity regarding his illness. On Valentine's Day, everyone gathers—except Mohammed—for a "lonely hearts club" dinner at the Stinking Rose Restaurant.