Surprise (S03E05)

Felicity is on a frantic mission to find Randy and uncover what really happened between them. While on a service call, Noel accidentally discovers a mass email from the fraternity featuring a nude photo of Felicity and Randy. He cautions her to stay quiet about it until after the surprise birthday party Ben has planned for her. Unfortunately, Richard and Molly accidentally reveal Felicity's secret during the celebration. Furious, Ben confronts the fraternity, where Randy's friends inform him that Felicity and Randy slept together. Randy reassures Felicity that nothing happened; she merely passed out, and he took care of her. Despite this, Ben feels betrayed and dismisses Felicity's denial. Meanwhile, Sean consults a doctor about swelling in one of his testicles, convinced it’s just an infection, but ultimately, Meghan persuades him to seek further help. He learns he needs surgery to check if the mass is malignant, shocking everyone involved.