Luck of the Draw (S02E18)

When Julius Hoffman arrives in town and challenges Matthew to a poker match, Matthew sees it as a golden opportunity to earn money for completing his and Ingrid's homestead, despite Mike and Sully's objections. Initially, luck is on Matthew's side, but a major fallout occurs with Ingrid when he misses a special dinner she prepared and reveals he used the laundry money she entrusted him with for building materials as poker stakes. Despite Ingrid and Mike's strong disapproval, Matthew persists in his gambling, even after he's beaten and robbed of his winnings. The townsfolk grow increasingly confident in his skills, rallying behind him for a significant poker game, except for Mike, Sully, and the Reverend. The Reverend discreetly informs Mike of his past gambling experiences with Julius and expresses concerns that the town might be falling into a trap. As Matthew heads to the big game, Ingrid ends their relationship over his gambling habits and returns the engagement ring.