Playing with Fire (S09E04)
S09E04
In 2001, a father is killed, his house in Florida is torched, and his sons vanish without a trace. As the community hopes for their safe return, a so-called family friend emerges, altering the direction of the investigation. An exclusive interview ultimately reveals the disturbing reality behind the events.
Show
People Magazine Investigates
Episode
S09E04
Air Date
Feb 02, 2026
Season 9 Episodes
S09E01
Vanished in the Heartland
S09E02
Death in Hell's Kitchen
S09E03
Sex House Homicide
S09E04
Playing with Fire
S09E05
The Serial Killer Who Only Killed Once
S09E06
Looking for Angela
S09E08
The Final Cut
S09E09
Love, Lies, and Lust
S09E10
Deadly Ride
S09E11
The Truth is in the Dirt
S09E12
Where is Judith?