Mystery on Lake Seminole (S04E06)

Jerry Michael Williams, a thriving businessman in Tallahassee, sets out on a solo duck-hunting expedition at Lake Seminole and mysteriously vanishes. Although his truck, boat, and shotgun are discovered, there’s no sign of Mike. Authorities initially suspect a tragic boating accident, but they are baffled by the absence of his body, making him the only drowning victim in the lake’s history to remain unfound. Given the alligator population in the area, a chilling theory emerges suggesting they may have devoured him. However, his mother dismisses this notion, holding onto hope that her son is alive while increasingly considering the possibility of foul play.