The List (S04E07)

Jude discovers that a pimple has brought him unexpected luck, while Wyatt spirals into sadness over his inability to find a girlfriend following a disastrous date. To help him out, Jonesy shares "The List," detailing girls he’s previously dated, which sparks a conflict between Wyatt and Nikki about their relationship timeline. Nikki ultimately decides they need a break until Jonesy can clarify his dating history with her. By the episode's end, Jonesy affectionately labels Nikki as "The One," a term Caitlin often uses for her own boyfriends. Meanwhile, at Albatross & Finch, Caitlin realizes her credit card is missing and, with Jen’s assistance, begins tracking its recent transactions to locate it.